You didn't have a hard task in front of you. Time, the internet, corniness/cheesiness and a rather original concept all combined to make and maintain a large fandom for a game show that hadn't aired an original episode since 1995 and has only been in shown in sporadic reruns since. I speak of course, of Legends of the Hidden Temple.
First of all, you do know who the Legends of the Hidden Temple demographic is, right? It's the present day 20 - 30 year olds who were old enough to watch the game show when it ran, and wish that they could've been on it. What does casting a 14 year old do for this audience? Nothing. All it does is make the movie appealing to a pre-teen to young teen group who have no attachment to the source material. So I really have no idea here what you're trying to accomplish by making this be a movie.
Now I'll admit, I enjoy watching reruns of the game show and watching the kids run through the temple. Why? Because a lot of the time the kids are terrible at it, and it's fun watching them fail spectacularly. Now that may sound mean, but it is also exciting to see one of the teams squeak out a victory right as time expires. That's the fun of the unscripted drama that is the game show; you don't know what's going to happen, and the competition can be engaging whether it's between adults, or kids.
This doesn't translate to a television movie in any way. It takes away the competitive element that crates legitimate drama, and substitutes in a scripted drama that's not going to be exciting to watch. And I'm sure you're going to say something to the extent of, "Oh well our writers and directors are going to make an exciting movie," but you're not. It's just going to be a typical made for TV movie that plays up to certain cliches and tropes that we've all seen before and isn't going to do anything revolutionary. Let's face it, you're not exactly Pixar making Inside Out to capture the imagination of kids and adults.
So again, who are you trying to serve with this film? Are you trying to play to the kids who don't know what Legends of the Hidden Temple stands for, or the adults who have no interest in watching a made for TV movie starring a 14 year old girl and being only tangentially related to a beloved property from their childhood?
Whose idea was it to make a game show into a TV Movie anyway? Why didn't you just bring the game show back? You do realize why we watched the show as kids, right? The show created a game that we felt like we could potentially be on that looked like amazing fun. We saw a temple that kids were running through that we know actually existed. It's not like this was a film set made to represent a fictional concept; this was an actual set made for kids to actually run through and compete in. It didn't matter if we could realistically go on the show or not, the fact was that it was even remotely possible, and that in itself is exciting.
Speaking of endearing, can we talk about the host, Kirk Fogg for a moment? Kirk was very likable but good lord could he stumble over his words like a drunk in a sand trap. If you listen to Kirk's commentary on the temple runs, it's abysmal. Here's a drinking game: take a shot every time Kirk misstates the name of one of the rooms in the temple: you will not make it past the first minute of the temple run; you just won't. Still, with all this, there's some sort of charismatic charm about Kirk that I can't deny.
See Nickelodeon, all you had to do was bring back the things that made Legends of the Hidden Temple work. Bring it back as a game show, bring back Kirk Fogg as a host, recreate the temple and the set, keep the rule set the same, and cast either kids or adults in the show. That's the great part about game shows, whether it's kids or adults playing, if you have an interesting format, it can still be fun to watch. Additionally, because of the property itself, adults are going to watch it anyway because it's more of what they liked to begin with.
Maybe you thought that reinventing Legends of the Hidden Temple would help bring parents and children together. Well, it could've done that as a game show, but thanks to the reasons I mentioned above, you've effectively isolated the potential adult demographic. I sincerely hoped you would've been smart enough to know how to handle your intellectual properties, but apparently I was wrong. People want the Legends of the Hidden Temple that we know we like, not the one that you think we should like. You might think it's clever to make a reference to "The Shrine of the Silver Monkey" in your movie and it will make the adult audience laugh, but that's missing the point. We don't want a reference to it, we want the actual shrine. We want the actual monkey. And more than anything, we want to see a bunch of people trying to put the damn thing together and win a trip to Space Camp for doing it. Well, for doing it ,grabbing the episode's artifact and making it back out of the temple in time; but we'll settle for the monkey.
The Critical Android